K.Sujatha: Murdered or Suicide or Cancer?

Who is the Senior Minister's Son and who is that Senior Minister?

Why the creamatorium was done so fast and none of the family members was allowed to see her for last respect?

One of the letter read as: Please help us, we are poor people. (The minister) and (his son) are powerful," read the letter written in broken Bahasa Malaysia, which named the minister and his son.

picture source: www.malaysiakini.com

Tahukah anda?

Tahukah anda, di Bandaraya Kuching terdapat satu lorong yang dikenali sebagai "Indian Street"? Walaupun kedai-kedai yang terdapat di lorong tersebut kini dimiliki oleh peniaga cina namun nama lorong tersebut terus dikekalkan dan Doi-Moi dimaklumkan masyarakat setempat tidak mempunyai apa-apa halangan untuk terus mengekalkannya. Tertanya kepada diri sendiri, apakah yang akan berlaku kepada nama lorong tersebut sekiranya lorong itu berada di Semenanjung Malaysia. Warganegara Malaysia yang menetap di Semenanjung patut belajar tentang hidup bersatu padu dari rakyat Sabah & Sarawak.

The India Street derives its name from the fact that it has always been a street occupied by the Indian shops. Most of the Indians are from the southern and northern India. At first it was called as the "Kling Street" in the 1850’s, but the Third White Rajah of Sarawak, Sir Charles Vyner Brooke changed the name to India Street in 1928. In 1992 the street was closed to vehicle traffic and converted into a pedestrian mall.

Surat terbuka kepada Ketua Pergerakan Pemuda UMNO

Kami, ahli-ahli muda MCA, menyokong penuh pendirian dan usaha murni MCA menyumbang kepada pembangunan negara dan rakyat Malaysia.Kami membidas tindakan Ketua Pergerakan Pemuda UMNO yang memberi “Amaran kepada MCA” melalui akhbar Berita Harian (tajuk utama, Sabtu 21 Julai 2007) yang meneruskan politik polemik mengintepretasikan semula perlembagaan persekutuan Malaysia. Ini berlaku walaupun pada hari Khamis 19 Julai, 2007, Kementerian Dalam Negeri telah mengarahkan media arus perdana supaya jangan menyiarkan sebarang berita mengenai Malaysia sebagai sebuah negara Islam. Perbuatan Ketua Pergerakan Pemuda UMNO langsung tidak menghormati larangan yang telah dikeluarkan oleh KDN yang mewakili kerajaan negara.Kenyataan Ketua Pergerakan Pemuda UMNO terhadap pemimpin MCA yang merupakan rakan kongsi utama BN, tidak membawa manfaat kepada sesiapa kerana ia tidak membawa kebaikan kepada mana-mana pihak.Kami memberi nasihat ikhlas kepada Ketua Pemuda UMNO supaya mengingati semangat BN yang telah menjadi teras kerjasama dan muafakat selama 49 tahun Malaysia merdeka. Perbuatan mengeluarkan amaran terhadap sesebuah rakankongsi seperjuangan BN juga memperlekehkan semangat toleransi, hormat-menghormati dan bermuafakat.Kami menyarankan pihak yang berkenaan seupaya melihat Perlembagaan Persekutuan Malaysia secara menyeluruh, bukannya mengambil sesuatu fasal atau fakta secara terasing kerana ini tindakan pihak yang jahil mengenai latar belakang, semangat dan kesefahaman yang telah dipersetujui di antara semua rakyat Malaysia yang menjadi teras membawa kepada pembentukan negara Malaysia yang merdeka.

Leadership Development Bureau

MCA Bangsar/22 July 2007

Sea King @ Nuri

SEA KING @ NURI

Tragedi ini dapat dielakkan sekiranya Kementerian Pertahanan telah mengambil langkah-langkah yang wajar untuk menyelamatkan nyawa para anggota wira-wira kita. Tetapi malangnya, tiada tindakan yang sewajarnya diambil menyebabkan negara kehilangan wira, isteri kehilangan suami, anak kehilangan ayah, ayah dan ibu kehilangan anak.

Ramai yang tidak tahu, sebenarnya Sea King @ Nuri telah dibeli oleh Kerajaan pada tahun 1968. Dalam tempoh masa 39 tahun sebanyak 18 kejadian telah berlaku dan hasilnya 95 kematian telah berlaku. Kejadian yang paling mengerikan berlaku pada 14 November 1989 apabila 21 orang termasuk 15 anggota Pasukan Polis Hutan terbunuh selepas Sea King @ Nuri terhempas antara Gunung Gerah dan Gunung Bilah di sempadan Kelantan-Perak. Sepatutnya keputusan dibuat untuk meletakkan Sea King @ Nuri di muzium tentera tetapi kita gagal berbuat sedemikian menyebabkan kemalangan terus berlaku. Malah kita masih tidak sedar diri kerana masih akan terus menggunakan Sea King @ Nuri sehingga ia digantikan dengan helicopter baru. [TPM kata perolehan tersebut akan dibuat secara tender antarabangsa menimbulkan persoalan kerana selama ini pembelian kemudahan/peralatan tentera dibeli secara rundingan terus atas justifikasi, keselamatan negara tetapi kenapakah perolehan helicopter baru ini hendak dibuat secara tender? Apakah kerana Razak Baginda berada di belakang pintu besi jadi tidak ada pegawai Kerajaan yang layak untuk membina spesifikasi atau tidak ada orang yang dipercayai oleh Menteri Pertahanan untuk mendapatkan "komisyen" bagi pembelian secara rundingan terus]

Walaupun keadaan cuaca dipersalahkan namun alasan tersebut bukannya dapat diterima oleh semua orang yang boleh berfikir secara rasional. Mungkin orang Pekan akan percaya kerana mereka masih menghormati Tun Abdul Razak.

Sebuah helicopter yang berusia 39 tahun sudah tentu akan berdepan dengan pelbagai masalah dan ketidakupayaan peralatan mekanikal untuk terus beroperasi di dalam keadaan cuaca yang tidak menentu. Andainya cuaca menjadi faktor utama, kenapakah helicopter tersebut dibenarkan membuat penerbangan?

Doi-Moi sangat berharap agar kejadian yang memilukan ini tidak berulang lagi dan sepatutnya Kerajaan mengambil pendirian untuk tidak membenarkan sebarang penerbangan menggunakan Sea King @ Nuri bagi mengelakkan sebarang kejadian lagi. Malangnya Kerajaan tidak mempunyai keupayaan untuk mengambil keputusan tersebut dan berselindung dengan alasan kononnya tidak ada helicopter lain untuk digunakan sebagai alternatif.

Satu persoalan yang ingin ditujukan kepada Menteri-menteri Kabinet Malaysia ialah, apakah Y.B. Menteri berani menggunakan Sea King @ Nuri untuk tujuan rasmi? Kalau anda tidak mempunyai keberanian untuk berbuat sedemikian kerana sayangkan nyawa, maka anda juga haruslah sayangkan nyawa pejuang-pejuang kita supaya tidak mati begitu sahaja.

Tertanya juga kenapa PM Malaysia yang ke 5 perlu membeli kapal terbang baru bernilai RM50 juta untuk kegunaan rasmi bila kita masih ada 20 Sea King @ Nuri? Kalau pembelian itu boleh dilakukan dalam masa yang singkat secara senyap kenapa kita memerlukan tempoh yang lama untuk menukar Sea King @ Nuri?

Secular State

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia is a secular state, insists the MCA.

It said the position was clear as evidenced by numerous historical documents, including the Reid Report, the Cobbold Commission and a 1988 Supreme Court decision. After reviewing the documents used in the process of drafting the Federal Constitution, the party’s secretary-general, Datuk Ong Ka Chuan, said Malaysia was a secular state based on the consensus and social contract agreed upon by the nation’s forefathers."The documents showed that a secular state is the foundation of the formation of Malaya and this consensus was made by our forefathers," he said yesterday.He said this in response to the statement by Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak on Monday that Malaysia is an Islamic nation that protects the rights of non-Muslims.

Citing an example, Ong said according to the Alliance’s memorandum to the Reid Commission dated Sept 27, 1956, it was stated on Page 19 that "The religion of Malaya shall be Islam. The observance of this principle shall not impose any disability on non-Muslim nationals professing and practising their own religion, and shall not imply the state is not a secular state." Ong said former prime minister Tunku Abdul Rahman Putra Al-Haj had said during a meeting on April 17, 1957, that "the whole constitution was framed on the basis that the federation would be a secular state".

Ong said notes prepared by the Colonial Office dated May 23, 1957, at the London Conference Talks mentioned that "the members of the Alliance delegation stressed that they had no intention of creating a Muslim theocracy and that Malaya would be a secular state".Additionally, Ong stated that when former MCA president, who was Finance Minister, Tun Tan Siew Sin spoke in parliament on July 10, 1957, in support of the Constitutional Bill, he said that although Islam would be the official religion, "this does not in any way derogate from the principle, which has always been accepted, that Malaya will be a secular state and that there will be a complete freedom to practise any other religion".Ong added that all these documents showed a true picture of Malaysia, which is a secular nation.

MCA central committee member and Kota Melaka MP Wong Nai Chee said Najib’s interpretation was "not in accordance with the spirit and intent of the Federal Constitution".He said that the issue of Malaya as a secular state was vigorously debated again during the 1962 Cobbold Commission before the entry of Sabah and Sarawak, forming Ma- laysia. "Again, the secular nature of Malaysia was reiterated as having been stated in the Reid Commission. The secular nature of our Federal Constitution has been the basis for our nation building since 1957 and reinforced in 1963.

"The Malaysian Consultative Council of Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Sikhism and Taoism president, Datuk A. Vaithilingam, urged the government and all Malaysians to respect the social contract agreed to in 1957.The council also strongly objected to attempts by the government to change the status quo.The Bar Council said that in the context of the country’s history and the constitution itself that proclaimed its supremacy, there was no doubt whatsoever that Malay- sia was a secular state.

"It is noteworthy that the prime minister in his speech delivered at the conference yesterday and in his propagating Islam Hadhari has never referred to Malaysia as an Islamic state," the council’s president Ambiga Sreeneva- san said. "It is time that the proposition that Malaysia is not secular (which is a rewriting of the constitution), be put to rest once and for all and that there is due recognition and reaffirmation of the clear legal and constitutional position that Malaysia is, and has always been, a secular state."

source: www.nst.com.my

SAY NO

RELIGIOUS BIGOTS MUST RESPECT HER DECISION. ALL THIS WHILE BARISAN NASIONAL/RELIGIOUS AUTHORITY SAID, SYARIAH COURT CAN GIVE NON-MUSLIM'S A FAIR TRIAL AND JUSTICE. BUT IN REVATHI'S CASE, IT'S PROVEN, NO JUSTICE TO HER AND HER HUSBAND. UNTIL NOW THEIR KID HAVE NO BIRTH CERTIFICATE DUE TO THE DENIAL OF MARRIAGE REGISTRATION. NOW IS THE TIME TO ASK BACK THE BN WHERE IS THE JUSTICE? NON MUSLIMS DEFINATELY WILL NOT GET THE JUSTICE IN SYARIAH COURT? DO NOT CLOSE YOUR EYE ON THIS DENIAL. USE YOUR VOTING POWER TO SAY NO TO THE INJUSTICE.

‘Revathi, that’s my name - forever’

‘Revathi, that’s my name - forever’

[Doi-Moi: Read the last sentence: "Because of their behaviour, I hate (benci) Islam even more now, religious bigots should shame on their self. What is the point they (religious bigots) ask her to remain as a muslim when now she hate more than before. Malaysia said as a Islamic country due to the muslims population but not a Islamic State. Malaysia's highest law is Constitutional Law not Al-Quran. Tun Dr. Mahathir declare Malaysia as "Negara Islam" for political gain but it was never declared as a "Islamic State". Wake up and fight for our rights as a citizens of this country.

Full Article

M Revathi, 29, still steadfastly wants to remain a Hindu, despite her six month detention by religious authorities and ongoing efforts to make her a Muslim.

“My name is Revathi. I want to hold on to that name - forever. I want to drop the name Siti Fatimah,” Revathi, sporting pottu (Hindu symbol) on her forehead, told reporters outside the Shah Alam High Court today.

Born Siti Fatimah Abdul Karim to Muslim convert parents, she was called Revathi Masoosai by the grandmother who raised her.

She married to V Suresh in 2004 according to Hindu rites and has a 18-month old daughter.

In January this year, Revathi was detained at the Malacca Syariah High Court when she attended a hearing over her application to have her official religious status be recognised as a Hindu.

She was detained at the court and subsequently held at the Ulu Yam religious rehabilitation camp in Selangor for six months until she was freed yesterday.

Speaking about her experience inside the camp, Revathi today described that she was subjected to ‘mental torture’ and claimed that she defied attempts to coerce her to follow religious classes.

“Their programmes are solely on religion. (There were also) prayer classes. I never attended (any of them). I only attended counselling. During counselling, they said I had to do this and that. They said I had to follow (religious) laws. I just buat tidak tahu (ignore).

“I argued that I had a right to choose my religion, but they replied that I should not talk about (my) rights,” said Revathi who is presently living with her Muslim parents as ordered by the religious authorities.

‘Many ran away’

She claimed that many had ran away from the ‘jail-like’ conditions of the camp but she had not.

“A lot of people ran away, even though (the camp was for Muslims). Though I’m a Hindu, I could bertahan (bear with the conditions), because I’m upholding the good name of Hinduism,” she added.

During her detention, she was not allowed visits. Recalling the only time she got to see her husband during her detention, Revathi said:

“Even though I was not allowed to meet my husband, I got to see him (standing) outside the camp, without their permission. I saw his car and I ran towards the fence. It was only once (I got to see him during the detention). After that, they (from the centre) dragged me away.

“Before, it was not enclosed. Now, they used zinc (sheets) to surround the area. You can’t see inside and we won’t know who is outside,” she said.

The emotional moment where Revathi and Suresh were momentarily reunited was captured on film by Al-Jazeera and aired on April 23 in current affairs programme Everywoman. [View video]

Revathi was initially detained for 80 days at the camp but her detention was extended for 100 days twice. Her stint ended yesterday when she was presented before the Malacca Syariah Court.

‘Waste of my time’

She was ordered to live with her parents and undergo counselling. She lamented that she was “unsatisfied” with the decisions made by the court.

“They held me for six months, only to say that I cannot leave Islam. If that is the case, they should have told me earlier, so I don’t have to go into the centre.

“Who’s going to compensate for the six months I was there? (It is a) waste of my time! I was separated from my child and husband. How are they going to compensate?” she asked.

“I have a right to choose my religion. In six months, they cannot make me change my mind, how can they do it now?”

She also said that religious officials tried to force her to pray, eat beef and wear a headscarf.

"Because of their behaviour, I hate (benci) Islam even more now," she added.

"Diviya Dharshini is now more than 18 months old and she has no birth certificate – an example of bureaucracy gone crazy - Y.B.Lim Kit Siang"

source: http://www.malaysiakini.com/

Manusia hipokrit

Beberapa tahun lalu, Ketua Pemuda MIC S.Vigneswaran (ketika itu belum bergelar Y.B.)berkata, "ada kalanya kita boleh menipu seseorang, ada kalanya kita boleh menipu semua orang tetapi kita tidak boleh menipu semua orang pada setiap masa". Hari ini Diktaktor Samy Vellu dan Pandithan berdepan dengan suasana yang demikian. Mereka boleh bersandiwara atas nama kepentingan masyarakat India tetapi masyarakat India sudah lama sedar akan sandiwara tersebut.

Dulu pandithan menggunakan, pelbagai kata-kata kesat kepada diktaktor tetapi hari ini tanpa segan silu meletakkan diktaktor setaraf dengan "Lord Krishna" manakala diktaktor yang selalu menamakan pandithan sebagai "gagak hitam" menjilat semula ludahnya dan memanggil pandithan sebagai adiknya.

Doi-Moi tidak kisah kalau pandithan dan diktaktor hendak memeluk dan mencium antara satu sama lain tetapi apa yang memilukan ialah pengikut samy & pandi masih tidak sedar sebenarnya mereka menjadi kuda tunggangan dalam krisis samy & pandi. Selagi ketidaksedaran ini wujud, selagi itulah akan ada manusia hipokrit seperti pandi dan samy.

penjara kerana curi 10 skru / 90sen

Membaca Harian Metro online hari ini menyentak hati. Seorang pencuci kereta di hukum penjara 13 bulan dan denda RM1,000 oleh Mahkamah Majistret di sini, semalam, selepas mengaku salah mencuri 10 batang skru besi milik Syarikat Bekalan Air Selangor Sdn Bhd (Syabas).

Bukan mahu membela perbuatan jenayah. Tetapi hati agak tersentak apabila membaca rayuan A Vijaya Kumar, 29. "Saya tinggal bersama tujuh adik beradik dan memberi sumbangan besar pendapatan kepada keluarga. Saya mencuri barangan terbabit disebabkan mengalami kesempitan hidup," rayunya kepada Majisterit.

Sememangnya ada rekod jenayah sebelum itu dan jika dia benar bersalah dia harus dihukum. Tetapi melalui kes ini rakyat perlu buka sedikit mata hati kita. Pendakwa raya dihadapan majisteret menyatakan "Perbuatan mencuri 10 batang skru besi milik Syabas menyebabkan syarikat terbabit mengalami kerugian besar akibat dari tindakan tidak bertanggungjawab seperti ini. Disebabkan tertuduh tidak insaf perlu diberikan hukuman setimpal."

Syabas yang mendapat keuntungan berbilion setiap tahun menjual air yang diturunkan tuhan. ( Nota ; Walaupun Malaysia berlebihan air sehingga banjir namun air tetap mahal dan malah kadang kala air tidak mencukupi - itu maknanya kerajaan (BN) dan syarikat kroninya gagal menguruskan sistem pengairan air negara). Dengan hanya kehilangan 10 skru pendakwa raya
menyifatkan Syabas telah kerugian besar.

Apakah pendakwaraya atau pejabat Peguam Negara hanya celik apabila kerugian itu ditanggung oleh syarikat (baca; golongan kapitalis) kroni kerajaan yang sememangnya sudah mewah dan lelap apabila kerugian itu menimpa rakyat yang sedia susah.

Laporan kedua hari ini ialah seorang remaja tingkatan empat dihantar ke Sekolah Pemulihan Henry Gurney kerana bersalah mencuri 90sen walaupun itu kesalahan pertamanya.

Mana pendakwaan rasuah yang berjuta malah berbilion (sehingga kini rasuah Rafidah Aziz dan Rahim Thamby Chik di senyapkan). Apa tindakan mereka apabila kerugian menimpa rakyat seperti apabila projek SMART (dah tukar nama ke Terowong Bestari untuk perbodoh rakyat) gagal ?

Siapa mahu tanggung kerugian satu juta yang dialami oleh dua sekolah kerana Smart yang gagal ? atau siapa yang mahu ambil tanggungjawab untuk tanggung anggaran awal 50 juta kerugian peniaga kecil di Kuala Lumpur yang memang sedia dari awal bertarung untuk menyara hidup ?

Yang pasti selepas gagal rakyat terus derita tetapi kerajaan (BN) akan terus menimmatinya kerana syarikat kroni akan terus menikmati kontrak baru, apabila kabinet meluluskan pengeluaran wang negara (Nota ; wang negara ialah wang kita yang dikutip dari cukai , saman dan sebagainya. Malah jagi menteri juga datangnya dari wang kita).

Rayuan....bukalah mata wahai rakyat tercinta.

Badrul Hisham (MPT Keadilan)
Inter-Asia Graduate School of NGO Studies, Songkonghoe University,
1-1 Hang-Dong, Guro-Gu, Seoul152-716 South Korea

source: http://chegubard.blogspot.com/

Most Valuable Precedent

Bridegroom P. Sanjeevi Rajan and bride R. Sasikalah performing wedding ritual in the presence of Narani yesterday.

PORT KLANG: K. Narani had always wanted to see her son married. But the tears of the guests at the wedding ceremony yesterday were of both joy and sorrow.

In a simple gesture of love for his mother, P. Sanjeevi Rajan married R. Sasikalah in front of his mother’s body during her funeral at the family’s house here.Fate had been cruel to the family, as 47-year-old Narani died of a heart attack in Chennai, India, on Sunday while shopping for sarees and other accessories for the wedding which had been originally scheduled for June 30.When her body was brought to the house at noon yesterday, Narani’s grieving husband Perumal suggested that Sanjeevi Rajan honour his mother’s dream of seeing her son married.Bride and groom consented, and after consulting with Sasikalah’s family, it was agreed that the wedding would go ahead.

Two priests were brought to the house, and between 2pm and 3pm, they conducted all the usual wedding ceremonies minus the yagna (fire ceremony).Sasikalah, 25, was dressed in a blue saree while Sanjeevi Rajan wore the traditional vesthi and jippa.Sanjeevi Rajan, 28, also performed the patha pooja, where he washed the feet of his parents.

For this ceremony, Perumal stood beside the body of Narani.The thali was then placed in the mother’s hand before Sanjeevi Rajan tied it around Sasikalah’s neck.Instead of the usual yellow rice, flowers were given to those present in the family hall to bless the couple.Later, Sanjeevi Rajan said though a marriage in such circumstances was unheard of, he was glad that it took place the way it did."I could have got married in the temple later, but would my mother be there? At least now, my mother is still here. My parents were side by side. It means the world to me."It’s both the saddest and happiest day for me in one go," he said wiping away his tears.Sasikalah said she was fortunate to have her wedding in front of her mother-in-law."

I got the chance to pay my last respects as the daughter-in-law and it means a lot to me."Her father, R. Rajaratnam, said when Perumal came up with the idea, he discussed it with family members and everyone felt that it was a good suggestion."It’s definitely worth it.

Narani wanted to see the wedding and Sanjeevi Rajan wanted his mother to be present at his wedding. Both got their wishes."As for the wedding invitations that have been sent out, Rajaratnam said everyone would be informed about what had happened.

However, he said the couple would get their marriage registered at the temple on June 30.

Samy Vellu Copy-Cat

This letter was sent by Jason L to Malaysiakini ..........

I refer to the report Samy pens poem for PM on Works Minister S Samy Vellu allegedly composing an original poem for Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi on occasion of the latter’s wedding.

I would like to bring your readers’ attention to the fact that Samy Vellu has plagiarised this poem. Do you know where he plagiarised the poem from? I reproduce below the original poems from which Samy Vellu had employed a ‘cut and paste’ operation.

From This Day Forward

Author Unknown

From this day forward,

You shall not walk alone.

My heart will be your shelter,

And my arms will be your home

Blessing For A Marriage

by James Dillet Freeman

May your marriage bring you all the exquisite excitements a marriage should bring, and may life grant you also patience, tolerance, and understanding.

May you always need one another - not so much to fill your emptiness as to help you to know your fullness. A mountain needs a valley to be complete; the valley does not make the mountain less, but more; and the valley is more a valley because it has a mountain towering over it. So let it be with you and you.

Now, below is Samy’s alleged poem:

‘From this day forward

You shall not walk alone.

Her heart will be your shelter,

And her arms will be your home.

A mountain needs a valley to be complete;

the valley does not makethe mountain less, but more;

and the valley is more a valley because

it has a mountain towering over it’

Really, how cheap can one get?

We will remember you Loga

Sad day for your listner, its a sad day for the music lover who take you and your group as a icon and role model to be a succesfull artist in music industry. We will remember you for ever. Condolence to Mrs.Loga, David and all your family members. We will miss you but your songs will always will be with us.

Lina Joy: What is freedom of religion?

Ronnie Liu wrote:

I find Nathaniel Tan's letter to editor (Malaysiakini) useful in understanding the issue of Lina Joy. I am reproducing it here for further discussion.I have, in my hands, a few cases of Muslim converts who wish to return to their previous religion. In that sense, their cases are slightly different from Lina who has renounced Islam ( a Malay who's born as a Muslim). In my mind, I think they should be allowed to go back to their original religion. Even for Lina Joy, I really do not see the logic and reason to force her to stay as a Muslim. It's pointless to keep a Muslim who has changed to other faith in his or her heart. I hold the the view that Lina should proceed to Syariah Courts to seek the permission to leave Islam. But to resolve cases similar to Lina in future, the Government must reform the Islam institutions in the country so that these institutions could handle such cases professionally. We do not need the courts to decide on conversion of religion, whether it's Islam or other religions.

But I do understand the strong feelings of some of my Muslim brothers and sisters. I know exactly where they were coming from.To them, they cannot accept a Muslim to leave Islam more of the fear factor (but you may argue that their fear was unfounded)rather than holding the view that Islam is a more superior religion. Yes, I do know that there were some who hold an extreme view that certain religion is more superior than other religion. But we do not have to agree with them.

I wish to tell all my Muslim brothers and sisters that there 's really no point to keep a Muslim if he or she has decided to embrace another religion.

My reasons are simply these:

1. All religions share the same root. We are all children of Abraham. All religions are ONE.

2. There's no such thing as a superior religion.

3. Other Muslims would not leave Islam just because Lina Joy was allowed to leave Islam.

4. Freedom of religion should include freedom to join and freedom to leave a particular religion.

5. Many have left Islam in the past but more have embraced Islam at the same time.

6. Like other religions, Islam is a good religion.

7. People who have left Islam without condemning it should not be seen as apostles.

8. Only people who condemn the religion (Muslim or Non-Muslim) could be considered as apostles and this must not be allowed in this country.

9. Malaysia, as a multi-religious society, needs freedom of religion for real harmony and peace among the peoples of different faith.

The Prime Minister's response on the Lina Joy's case is pathetic. He just want to wash his hands and pretend that he has got nothing to do with it. He has once again failed to carry out his duty and responsibility as the prime minister of this country.

I hope bloggers could also give their views on this important issue. Please leave your comments with Colour-blind.

BTW, DAP will be holding a forum to discuss the case on 7 June 2007 in Petaling Jaya. Watch this blog closely for further details.

source: www.malaysia-today.net

Nalla oh Nalla

Doi-Moi berpendapat Dato' Nalla telah mengambil satu tindakan yang tidak rasional di mana beliau meletakkan jawatan dan keluar dari Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) sehari sebelum mesyuarat agung tahunan yang menyaksikan pertandingan untuk jawatan-jawatan utama parti. Sekiranya Dato' Nalla mempunyai semangat perjuangan beliau patut mempertahankan keputusan asalnya untuk bertanding jawatan Naib Presiden. Peluang untuk beliau menang berdasarkan pencalonan yang diterimanya adalah tinggi. Sebagai seorang pejuang politik beliau patut meneruskan hasrat untuk bertanding walaupun Anwar sendiri memberikan nasihat untuk beliau memberi laluan kepada Azmin. Doi-Moi berpendapat Dato' Nalla sebenarnya tidak mempunyai ciri-ciri seorang pejuang yang tulen dan berani berdepan dengan risiko. Apa gunanya beliau menyalahkan orang lain bila beliau sendiri tidak berani untuk berdepan dengan cabaran politik. Selamat Bersara Dato' Nalla, gunakanlah masa yang ada bersama keluarga.

Political Decision

The decision has been made, but i dont think its a "constitutional decision" but made based on political situation which i called it as a "political decision." Its a sad day for those who are struggling for the freedom to practice the religion. Its a open secret that she has converted to christianity, so i dont see the victory as "proclaimed" by some religious bigots. On paper her religion will be "Islam" but by soul she will not. If she die in Malaysia, religious authority will get her body but definately will fail to get her soul. If you are strong enough in your stand as what you are, then the religious authority dont need the law to put those who decided to renounce behind the bar just to make he/she to remain as a muslim. The decision has not solved the problem and this type of cases will prolonged and in future we will see more cases which will create more tension and will widen the gap on our unity. If you love this country and you believe you are part of this country, then you can make a changes. How? Show your disatisfaction on ballot paper.

Datuk Richard Malanjum on his dissenting judgement said "it was not the function of the NRD to ensure that Lina had properly apostasised as such a matter should be left to the relevant religious authorities to take any action as deemed necessary. The NRD has not shown that one of its statutory duties is to ensure that a person has properly renounced the Islamic faith in accordance with the requirements of the Islamic authorities. The principle of administrative law stated that a public authority must not act mechanically and must consider each case on its merits."